THE FINAL ACT:
On January 30, 2002, John Conyers Jr., the ranking Democrat on the House Judiciary
Committee wrote in the New York Times:
Voting Rights in Peril
By JOHN CONYERS JR.
January 30, 2002, New York Times Op-Ed.
WASHINGTON -- At the heart of the debate over reforming the nation's
electoral system lies the question of whether standards for voting should be
set by the federal government or left up to state and local election officials.
It is hardly a surprise that the Election Reform Information Project found, in
a survey released last week, that state and local officials would prefer to
continue exercising exclusive authority over federal elections. But it is
disappointing nonetheless. The national voting rights standards that I have
pushed for in the House and that Senator Christopher Dodd has pressed in
the
Senate
provide
fundamental
safeguards
that
should
have
been
guaranteed long ago.
The House has unwisely passed a bill that grants states nearly unfettered
discretion in the administration of elections. The Senate is set to take a more
aggressive approach. The real question for the committee that will reconcile
the differences is not what state and local officials prefer, but what will
guarantee that the problems with our elections will be fixed.
At a minimum, the states should be required to provide accessible and well-
functioning machines for citizens who speak languages other than English
and for those with disabilities. Voters who have been wrongly purged from
registration records should be allowed to cast provisional ballots.
America has tried leaving election decisions to each state. We have no
minimum federal voting rights standards for voting machines. The result: In
the 2000 presidential election, 1.5 million ballots were discarded due to
defective
voting
equipment.
We
have
no
minimum
federal
standards
guaranteeing the right of a voter with a disability to cast a private and
independent vote. The result: In 2000, 47 percent of voters with disabilities
encountered physical barriers or had trouble getting to the polling place.
State and local officials say they will eventually make necessary changes on
their own. History teaches us, however, that states have been slow in
outlawing discrimination. In 1868, the 14th Amendment was adopted,
guaranteeing black citizens the rights and privileges of citizenship. In the
name of states' rights, implementation was left to local control. This model
failed, and federal legislation became necessary: Without the Civil Rights